How historic district review works
Pennsylvania's Historic District Act lets cities, boroughs and townships create historic districts. Property owners in a certified district need a Certificate of Appropriateness before altering a historic building, and the municipality appoints a Historical Architectural Review Board (HARB) to review the applications. Most local guidelines focus on what can be seen from the street, so a fence along the front or side of a lot is more likely to be reviewed than one behind the house.
Sources: PHMC: planning ordinances and the Historic District Act
West Chester Borough
West Chester's HARB design guidelines say wood picket, vertical board, stockade and ornamental iron fences are found in the Historic District. Split-rail, chain-link and plastic fences aren't considered appropriate except at the rear of a lot. Fences along the street should be refined or ornamental and let people see the yard and building, while side and rear fences can be more solid, and gates should swing into the private walk or driveway rather than over the sidewalk.
Phoenixville Borough
Phoenixville's HARB reviews site features, including walls and fences, when changes are visible from a street, sidewalk or public way. Its guidelines list chain link fencing and vinyl fencing among the materials they discourage. The borough's fence permit application also asks whether the property is in the historic district.
Sources: Phoenixville HARB Design Guidelines, Phoenixville fence permit application
Birmingham Township
Birmingham Township, around Chadds Ford and Dilworthtown, has a rural historic district with its own guidelines. Outside the village, new fences should be open in design and up to 5 feet tall, in wood pickets, post and rail or split rail. Fence applications need a site plan showing where the fence goes and an elevation drawing of it.
Sources: Birmingham Township Historic District Design Guidelines
Before you choose a style
If your property might be in a historic district:
- Ask your borough or township whether the property is in a historic district
- Get a copy of the district's design guidelines and look for the fence section
- Plan for HARB review time before the permit is issued
- Bring a site plan and a drawing or photo of the fence style to the application

