At a glance
Rust
- Aluminum
- Forms a protective oxide layer and resists moisture and soil
- Wrought iron / steel
- Rusts when the coating fails; exposed iron can corrode in months
Upkeep
- Aluminum
- Low: occasional cleaning
- Wrought iron / steel
- Keep the paint intact; sand, prime and repaint rust spots
Weight
- Aluminum
- Lightweight, about four times lighter than steel
- Wrought iron / steel
- Heavy and very sturdy
What you're actually buying
- Aluminum
- Aluminum
- Wrought iron / steel
- Usually steel: true wrought iron is rarely used in modern fencing
| Aluminum | Wrought iron / steel | |
|---|---|---|
| Rust | Forms a protective oxide layer and resists moisture and soil | Rusts when the coating fails; exposed iron can corrode in months |
| Upkeep | Low: occasional cleaning | Keep the paint intact; sand, prime and repaint rust spots |
| Weight | Lightweight, about four times lighter than steel | Heavy and very sturdy |
| What you're actually buying | Aluminum | Usually steel: true wrought iron is rarely used in modern fencing |
Sources: U.S. GSA: Aluminum characteristics, National Park Service, This Old House: metal fences
Why aluminum is low-maintenance
Aluminum protects itself with a layer of aluminum oxide and holds up well against weather, moisture and soil, according to the U.S. General Services Administration. That's why it's popular around pools and in yards where nobody wants to repaint a fence.
One caution from the same source: when aluminum touches other metals such as iron or steel, galvanic action can corrode the aluminum, so hardware and fasteners should be compatible.
Sources: U.S. GSA
What 'wrought iron' usually means today
Historic wrought iron is soft, tough and easy to forge, which is why old ornamental fences have such detailed work. Today, as This Old House notes, what's marketed as wrought iron is often solid steel, because true wrought iron is rarely used in modern fencing.
Iron and steel both rust when moisture and air reach bare metal. The National Park Service notes that exposed iron can corrode in as little as six months, and that every paint coating eventually cracks, so keeping the finish intact is the main upkeep.
Sources: NPS Preservation Brief 27, NPS: When the Rust Settles, This Old House
Which one should you choose?
A quick way to decide:
- Choose aluminum for low upkeep, around a pool, or anywhere you'd rather not repaint.
- Choose iron or steel for the heaviest, most solid feel, or to match historic ironwork, and plan on keeping the paint up.
- Either way, check your township's height rules, and pool barrier rules if it surrounds a pool.


